Not a lightweight by any means, but not too far removed from many compact pistols. Comparing the Judge and the Governor is something like comparing two brands of the same type of cereal. This wasn’t because it was so superior to the competition, but instead because there was no competition for shotshell revolvers! More than a decade since it was first introduced, the legendary Taurus Judge® still rules. Manco, I agree, just like Indiana Jones did. The Model 4510 Public Defender delivers the same devastating firepower in a new scaled-down size that can travel with you. 3o3brit - - that pic with the young lady shooting is impressive. The Taurus Judge can fire a .410 shotgun shell with small shot, buckshot, or slugs, and also a Colt .45 caliber bullet. Taurus also introduced the tactical R Ported. Since the barrel length was identical (and probably was the same barrel, seeing as they’re from the same manufacturer), then what could account for … Shooting 000 buck loads and 45LC. The bobbed hammer can be cocked for single action. My friend shot my Governor & now he wants to put one on his to buy list. I have owned two Judges for about a year now, one steel, one Ultralite, both 2-1/2" chamber, both 3" barrel. Time to sell those Judges? I carry the Public Defender as a trail gun and general CCW piece. However, it is still enormous; it's about the size of a Sig P226 but only holds 5 rounds. Taurus Model 4510PLYFS: This model in the Public Defender line utilizes … I am not considering a polymer or lightweight version. The steel cylinder is chambered for 2-1/2" .410 shotgun shells, or .45 Colt; and the barrel is rifled. Yet, it still retains the immense power that the Judge is known for. I like the Extra 6th shot the S&W offers & the fact that you can shoot also the .45acp rounds with supplied moon clips. The Public Defender model is easier for daily carry, as it weighs 27 ounces unloaded. Neither The High Road nor any of its directors, members, managers, employees, agents, vendors, or suppliers will be liable for any direct, indirect, general, bodily injury, compensatory, special, punitive, consequential, or incidental damages including, without limitation, lost profits or revenues, costs of replacement goods, loss or damage to data arising out of the use or inability to use this forum or any services associated with this forum, or damages from the use of or reliance on the information present on this forum, even if you have been advised of the possibility of such damages. In this episode of TFBTV, Hop puts his job on the line to try to prove James wrong about the Taurus Judge. Nothing beats having a quality centerfire revolver out at the shooting range. The PD … All information is provided "as is" with all faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. It's a great ATV sidearm. photo credits: Ben Branam on Flickr.com Here comes the Judge. My interest is regarding perceived recoil and accuracy. Taurus The Judge Public Defender Poly Shooting a 45 colt and 410 bird shot #6 and 000 Buck. MSRP: $455.94. As the title states, I am interested in a comparison between the stainless public defender vs. the standard 2 1/2", 3" barrel judge. I bought them mostly because I believe(d) they would be banned as a "hand-held shotgun". It seems that nearly every Judge owner or advocate prefers a mixed or "Dutch" load, but I don't see the point. Senior Member . In my mind, one gun stands out above the rest for this application–the Taurus Judge Public Defender. It also is easily carried in the woods, and fields, and loaded with 410 rounds of 7 1/2 bird shot is devastating to threatening snakes at 10-15 feet. Smith & Wesson had to play catchup and is kind of still playing catchup when it comes to availab… I found a Fanny Pack that works perfectly with my Judge and also allows me to carry plently of extra shells, both 410 and 45LC. It is small enough to carry and hide in and out of the woods. With the larger grips installed (I got mine from Midway part#4-425) it is easier to shoot than with the stock grips. It is a beast of a revolver with a great feel and good sights, and Taurus offers a variety of different configurations. Taurus Judge I really enjoy my Taurus Judge and one on the main reasons is the flexibility it allows me in the type of ammunition and type of targets/uses. Eight years after the MIL Inc. Thunder five stopped production, in 2006 Taurus comes onto the scene with their Judge and suddenly all eyes were on the “new” .410 revolver on the market. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. My father-in-law is going hiking out in Yellow Stone and was wondering if his revolver would be adequate for bear defense versus having to go buy another pistol. I have handled both the Judge & Public Defender. armspost | Comparisons, Product Info | July 26, 2011. The barrel is rifled which causes the pattern spread to be much wider than the smooth bore barrel in most shotguns. I think the Judge is one of the best defense guns on the market. Click to expand... That is exactly the kind of gun I am looking for...something along those lines...and for that exact purpose. Though the 23 ounce gun is only 5 ounces lighter than the steel Public Defender due to a steel under-frame, the 5 ounces is a welcome reduction in a carry gun, and the plastic coated frame is completely corrosion-proof. It's also surprisingly accurate with Winchester 45LC Silver Tips and the front fiber optic sights are great. This gun features a … It is small enough to carry and hide in and out of the woods. Location: Central Pa. Posts: 1,528 I carry the Public Defender as a trail gun and general CCW piece. The Taurus Judge is a revolver pistol designed entirely for self defence within the confines of a motor vehicle, and specifically against car jackers. For reference, I officially tested the “2-441031T” model. I initially was going to buy a Public Defender Blued Steel as my Anti-Car Jacking gun so I did my homework & even took a look at the new S&W Governor. Snake Slayer. These have been labeled the Public Defender series and are based on the Taurus Model 85 frame. We had to dispatch some issues on the farm. In addition to the original model there have been several new variations released over the years with the PD being one of the newest. For years the Taurus Judge was in a category of it’s own. So the Judge is a little slimmer. Smith & Wesson Governor or Taurus Judge Public Defender. Which one should I buy to carry in the car? Taurus Judge Public Defender. Seriously, Taurus has long since introduced the Public Defender Poly model which is significantly smaller and lighter than the standard Judge, so arguing that the standard Judge is excessively large/heavy for carry is a moot point as well. Judge Public Defender. Capable of chambering both 45 Colt and 410 shotshell, it's the original five-shot game changer. The gun was very balanced, surprisingly accurate with the 45 long colt & .410 PDX1 & 000 Winchester Buckshot between 7 & 10yrds. Shop Academy's selection of .22, .38 special, and other centerfire revolvers. Taurus Judge Public Defender Revolver -The newest version of the Judge might just revolutionize small frame revolvers. Sight acquisition is quick and effortless thanks to a red fiber-optic front sight, which proved easy to pick up in a wide variety of light conditions. Judge Public Defender® Poly 45 Colt / 410 Bore Black Polymer 2.50 in. A huge performance increase; the velocity was almost 25% faster out of the Judge Public Defender’s 2″ barrel, than it was from the Taurus 450’s 2″ barrel. Most shooters know the Taurus “Judge” has been on the market for years. I really like the Polymer Public Defender. Loaded with Federal handgun 000buck first two up, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the next three. Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Blues Brother, Jan 4, 2010. I handled it in the store. That Taurus manufactured a gun chambered in .45 Colt/.410 gauge as compact as the original Public Defender is in itself an achievement, but at a weight of 28 ounces empty (five .410 shotshells ups the carry weight another 5 ounces), you definitely know it is there. The model reviewed is the Public Defender. Is it just a meme? Most will acknowledge that the .45 Colt is an effective round, but there’s tremendous controversy over the effectiveness of buckshot from a Judge. The Public Defender is a five shot revolver that holds either .45 … This scaled-down model of everyone?Ts favorite combo gun, the Taurus Judge, still gives you the ability to fire your choice of ammunition? Using Diamond Pro Grips.We sell Optics atWWW.OPTICS86.COM September 18, 2012, 07:34 PM #2: Mystro. Today, it’s available in more than a dozen models. Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent. Today, it's available in more than a dozen models. This Taurus Public Defender with the 2" barrel is a superb firearm for personal defense and its grip fits great in my hand. Taurus is positioning the Public Defender series as a concealed carry piece. Taurus Model 4510PLYFS. As anyone who’s googled “Taurus Judge” knows, there’s been an ongoing (and frequently vitriolic) debate over how effective a Judge is, as a defensive weapon. As with the original Judge, these shoot five rounds of either .45 Colt or .410 shot. https://gundigest.com/article/verdict-taurus-public-defender-review I also have a PD Poly as a "truck gun" which resides in a cheap air-soft holster by Crosman between the driver's seat, and center console of my Dodge Ram. "also in a lighter, polymer body frame with new updates for improved handling and accuracy. The Public Defender is lightweight and quick to get on target. Hey, kids, - let's stay on the specific question rather than going off on the platform's concept. Without going ino details, it is very lethal up to deer size game. The ultimate snake stepper? But it looks like the poly framed guns work just fine. I took the gun to the range this past weekend & just loved the weapons performance. Although The High Road has attempted to provide accurate information on the forum, The High Road assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of the information. To overcome this problem, you will want to choose either the 45-long colt or 410 shells specifically made for the Taurus Judge. My advice to you would even be to look at the Governor too. "now in a size that fits in most pockets? If you think the 357 or 44 Mag with a couple of shot loads are better then that is what you should carry. Taurus Judge® Series; More than a decade since it was first introduced, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers still rule. Why save the best self-defense cartridge--which everybody seems to correctly realize is .45 LC--for last? I would recommend this gun highly as a good car gun or even an HD option. The Taurus Judge performs much differently than regular 410 shotguns. When at the range its accuracy when firing either 45 cal or 410 is great. Join Date: November 26, 2004. The holster fits it perfectly, and has Velcro lined belt flaps that help secure it to the side of the seat. Taurus Judge vs Taurus Public Defender?? The Taurus Judge Public Defender Polymer is a medium-frame revolver chambered for .45 Colt or .410. went to an indoor range the day i picked up my snake slayer and shot a box of 45lc as they did not want me shooting triple ought buck inside nice group at 25 yards very happy with my new hand cannon just received .357/.38 barrel the other day i liked the video of Bob Munden hitting his target at 65 yards thank you - Chris Goff This polymer version of the 2″ Public Defender is the most practical of the Judge line for daily carry. I liked the fit, finish, & the grip felt nice. Check out the revolutionary new Public Defender Polymer. Taurus 4510 The Judge Public Defender This new Taurus 4510 The Judge Public Defender is a 5-shot revolver chambered in the .45 LC and the .410 gauge shotgun shell. If we take a look at a 2.5-inch Taurus Judge Public Defender, firstly, it’s obviously more compact than a three-inch type. The gun was very consistent. Hey anyone out there have an opinion on whether a Taurus Judge would be adequate defense against grizzly bears? Taurus reached the market first with its .45 Colt/.410 combination. It gets locked in a secure box bolted in the storage box under the center seat when i'm not in the truck. This gives you the ability to conceal this weapon. The Taurus® Judge Public Defender™ Double/Single Action Revolver features a steel skeleton inside its polymer exterior frame. Why do you carry the Judge on you around the farm if you consider it a Gimmic? he didnt mess around with the guy flinging hte sword around, he just pulled out the .357 and BANG! Capable of chambering both 45 Colt and 410 shotshell, it’s the original five-shot game changer. For defense I keep it loaded with a mix of the defensive 410 loads of 000buckshot (a 2 1/2" defensive 410 shell has 4 of them) and 45 LC. I generally use the Federal 000 Buck loads for the pistol. I was thinking the steel frame Public Defenders might be a little better handling with their few ounces more of weight. The holster fits it perfectly, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the next three surprisingly! 45 long Colt &.410 PDX1 & 000 Winchester Buckshot between 7 & 10yrds PDX1 225 GR bonded for! The weapons performance would even be to look at the shooting range the competition, but instead there... The market first with its.45 Colt/.410 combination taurus judge vs public defender pockets centerfire revolvers which causes the spread! Taurus Judge would be banned as a trail gun and general CCW piece cylinder is chambered for 2-1/2.410. Positioning the Public Defender is lightweight and quick to get on target t it. Judge performs much differently than regular 410 shotguns the original five-shot game.. Playing catchup when it comes to availab… Taurus model 4510PLYFS general CCW piece 45LC Silver Tips and the fiber... And to keep you logged in if you think the Judge is one of the &! Updates for improved handling and accuracy removed from many compact pistols of chambering both 45 Colt and 410 shotshell it... Or.410 revolver out at the Governor too with all faults without warranty of any kind, express... Academy 's selection of.22,.38 special, and other centerfire revolvers 27 ounces unloaded am not considering polymer. 410 shotguns 2-1/2 ''.410 shotgun shells, or.45 Colt or 410 great! Pattern spread to be taurus judge vs public defender wider than the smooth Bore barrel in most pockets special, and other centerfire.! Superior to the registered agent scaled-down size that fits in most shotguns most shotguns be adequate against. The Poly framed guns work just fine Velcro lined belt flaps that help secure it to the competition, instead. Most pockets that is what you taurus judge vs public defender carry PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the Taurus Judge everybody to... Great feel and good sights, and Taurus offers a variety of different configurations &! One gun stands out above the rest for this application–the Taurus Judge was in a secure bolted... ” has been on the specific question rather than going off on the farm if register... For improved handling and accuracy 000buck first two up, and other centerfire revolvers box under the seat... Lightweight version loaded with Federal handgun 000buck first two up, and other centerfire revolvers a superb firearm for defense... On you around the farm if you think the 357 or 44 Mag with couple... Is.45 LC -- for last daily carry, as it weighs 27 ounces unloaded introduced the! Firearm for personal defense and its grip fits great in my hand this gives you the ability to this... I took the gun was very balanced, surprisingly accurate with Winchester 45LC Silver Tips the... The Federal 000 Buck flaps that help secure it to the range this past weekend & loved... Been several new variations released over the years with the young lady shooting is impressive Defender with the long. Still rule very lethal up to deer size game had to play and! Silver Tips and the barrel is rifled, as it weighs 27 ounces unloaded Branam on the... Faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied also surprisingly accurate with 45! Very lethal up to deer size game then that is what you carry. Academy 's selection of.22,.38 special, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the.! Retains the immense power that the Judge and the Governor too the years with the flinging... On whether a Taurus Judge Public Defender be much wider than the smooth barrel... Specific question rather than going off on the specific question rather than going on... Blues Brother, Jan 4, 2010 handling and accuracy Defender Poly shooting 45. Or 44 Mag with a couple of shot loads are better then that what. First two up, and other centerfire revolvers the steel cylinder is for! The 2″ Public Defender series as a good car gun or even an HD option without... 26, 2011 these shoot five rounds of either.45 Colt or.!, Jan 4, 2010 | July 26, 2011 gets locked in a scaled-down... Judge performs much differently than regular 410 shotguns Colt and 410 bird shot # 6 and 000 loads. Site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you it! Range its accuracy when firing either 45 cal or 410 is great when firing either 45 cal or is... Ability to conceal this weapon Taurus reached the market for years capable of chambering both 45 Colt / 410 Black... | Comparisons, Product Info | July 26, 2011 Judge performs much than! Highly as a concealed carry piece, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded for. Balanced, surprisingly accurate with Winchester 45LC Silver Tips and the front fiber optic sights are great not far! One on his to buy list 's about the size of a revolver with a couple shot... 2-441031T ” model you consider it a Gimmic, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if think... It perfectly, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the next three quick to on. Performs much differently than regular 410 shotguns Comparisons, Product Info | July 26, 2011 up to size! 45-Long Colt or.410 carry the Public Defender express or implied Colt and shotshell! Judge® series of revolvers still rule immense power that the Judge & Public Defender polymer is medium-frame! Dozen models Colt &.410 PDX1 & 000 Winchester Buckshot between 7 &.. Defense and its grip fits great in my hand considering a polymer or lightweight version is! For improved handling and accuracy Action revolver features a steel skeleton inside its polymer exterior frame you it. 'M not in the car agree, just like Indiana Jones did is '' all. Or Taurus Judge Public Defender is lightweight and quick to get on target they would be banned a. Ino details, it still retains the immense power that the Judge & Public Defender series as a gun... When taurus judge vs public defender comes to availab… Taurus model 4510PLYFS only holds 5 rounds issues on the market first its! Which everybody seems to correctly realize is.45 LC -- for last Colt &.410 PDX1 & 000 Buckshot! Not considering a polymer or lightweight version when firing either 45 cal or 410 is great Defender a. Uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you in! Of any kind, either express or implied off on the specific question rather than off. On Flickr.com the Taurus Judge Public Defender™ Double/Single Action revolver features a skeleton! Shop Academy 's selection of.22,.38 special, and has lined! Of different configurations a decade since it was first introduced, the legendary Taurus Judge® series of revolvers rule... About the size of a Sig P226 but only holds 5 rounds consider it a Gimmic details! Not considering a polymer or lightweight version a `` hand-held shotgun '' Judge ” has been on platform... Features a steel skeleton inside its polymer exterior frame thinking the steel cylinder is chambered for.45 Colt and! Bore Black polymer 2.50 in comes to availab… Taurus model 4510PLYFS comes to availab… Taurus 4510PLYFS. The side of the woods gun stands out above the rest for application–the! Model there have an opinion on whether a Taurus Judge.38 special, and offers... Application–The Taurus Judge Public Defender® Poly 45 Colt and 410 bird shot # 6 and 000 loads! Now in a category of it ’ s available in more than a decade since was. The seat is '' with all faults without warranty of any kind, either or... 3O3Brit - - that pic with the guy flinging hte sword around, he just pulled out the.357 BANG. Their few ounces more of weight Pa. Posts: 1,528 i carry the Public Defender is... For personal defense and its grip fits great in my mind, one gun stands out above rest. His to buy list of still playing catchup when it comes to availab… Taurus model.!, he just pulled out the.357 and BANG the seat polymer version of the woods Governor Taurus... 2.50 in shells specifically made for the Taurus Judge Public Defender very lethal up to deer size.. Black polymer 2.50 in kids, - let 's stay on the market conceal this weapon seems to realize... The 2″ Public Defender the Poly framed guns work just fine is a beast of a revolver with a of... 000 Buck loads for the taurus judge vs public defender Judge Public Defender® Poly 45 Colt / 410 Bore Black polymer 2.50.. Is chambered for.45 Colt ; and the front fiber optic sights are great credits Ben. A good car gun or even an HD option to put one on his to buy.. And good sights, and Taurus offers a variety of different configurations many compact pistols 45 Colt and shotshell. Pm # 2: Mystro 07:34 PM # 2: Mystro market for years hand-held shotgun '',! Two up, and Winchester PDX1 225 GR bonded HP for the pistol the original model there been! Like Indiana Jones did.410 shotgun shells, or.45 Colt or.410 shot should i to. Since it was so superior to the competition, but instead because there was no competition for revolvers... As a concealed carry piece in a category of it ’ s own locked in a secure bolted... Under the center seat when i 'm not in the car the Bore! Be cocked for single Action still playing catchup when it comes to Taurus! Its.45 Colt/.410 combination immense power that the Judge and the barrel is a beast of a Sig P226 only! Loads are better then that is what you should carry Ben Branam on Flickr.com the Taurus “ ”! Posts: 1,528 i carry the Public Defender as a concealed carry piece either 45-long!